Article – Business Management
Chapter 8
8-16© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall 8-17
Unique
Common
Standardized
Commoditized
Utility
Figure 8.1 Maturity for IT Function Delivery
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Unique:
A unique IT function is one that provides strategic
(perhaps even proprietary) advantage and benefit.
Common:
This type of IT function caters to common (i.e.,
universal) organizational needs. It has little to
differentiate the business, but it provides a necessary
component (e.g., HR, financial system).
8-18
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Standardized:
An IT function that not only provides common
tasks/activities but also adhere to a set of standards
developed and governed by external agencies.
Commoditized:
These functions are considered commodities similar to
oil and gas. Once attributes are stipulated, functions are
interchangeable and indistinguishable (e.g., ASPs,
network services, server farms, backup services).
8-19
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Utility:
A utility function is a commodity (such as electricity)
delivered by a centralized and consolidated source (e.g.,
ISPs, other telecommunication services such as
bandwidth on demand).
8-20
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall 8-21
Figure 8.2 IT Functions Ranked by Maturity Stage
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
In-house
Insource
Outsource
Partnership
8-22
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall 8-23
Figure 8.3 Delivery Options for IT Functions
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
1. Flexibility:
Response time (i.e., how quickly IT functionality can be
delivered).
Capability (i.e., the range of IT functionality).
2. Control:
Delivery (i.e., ensuring that the delivered IT function
complies with requirements).
Security (i.e., protecting intellectual assets).
8-24
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
1. Knowledge Enhancement:
Behind many sourcing decisions is the need to either
capture knowledge or retain it.
2. Business Exigency:
Unforeseen business opportunities arise periodically, and
firms with the ability to respond do so. That is, a quick
decision is made to seize the opportunity, and normal
decision criteria are jettisoned in order to be responsive
to the business.
8-25
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Identify your core IT functions.
Create a “function sourcing” profile.
Evolve full-time IT personnel.
Encourage exploration on the whole range
of sourcing options.
Combine sourcing options strategically.
8-26
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall 8-27
Core Function? IT Function In-house Insource Outsource Partnership
Yes Business analysis
Systems analysis
In Future Strategy and planning
In Future Data management
Yes Project management
Yes Architecture
Application development
QA and testing
Now but not in
future
Networking
Operating systems and services
Yes Application support
Data center operations
Application software
Hardware
Table 8.3 Sample Function Delivery Profile
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Develop a sourcing strategy
Use a decision framework to identify what’s core and
what’s not.
Develop a risk mitigation strategy
Ideally, an outsourcing relationship should be structured
to ensure shared risk so both parties are incented to
make it work.
8-28
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Understand the cost structures
If you can’t compete in-house, you should outsource.
Ongoing cost comparisons are effective as they motivate
both parties to do their best and most cost-effective
work.
8-29
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Sourcing has become an integral part of
many organizations.
IT managers have an incredible range of
available options in terms of how they
choose to source and deliver IT functions.
Based on the framework proposed,
organizations can develop more strategic,
nuanced, and methodological approaches
to IT function sourcing and management.
8-30
Chapter 9
9-31© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Takes too long.
Process may be disconnected from the
business objectives.
Rigid adherence to annual plans may
inhibit responsibility for performance.
May inhibit the business needs to be
flexible.
9-32
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Organizational budgeting practice
emerged in the 1920s as a tool for
managing costs and cash flows.
Present-day annual fixed plans and
budgets were established in the 1970s to
drive performance improvements.
9-33
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Fiscal IT budget (i.e., those prepared
for the CFO):
— Capital expenditures – consist of large
expenses spread over multiple years.
— Operating Expenses – consist of the
annual costs of running the business.
9-34
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Capital budgets
IT Expenditures that may be capitalized
include:
— Project development
— Infrastructure
— Consulting fees
— Major technology purchases
9-35
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Functional IT budgets
Used by IT managers as spending plans
and are based on:
— Operations costs
— Strategic investment
9-36
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Operations costs:
— Costs to “Keep the Lights On”.
— Includes maintenance costs, computing
and peripheral functions, in-house
support and outsourced support.
— May include operating and capital
costs.
9-37
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Strategic investment:
— Consists of “New” technology spending.
— May include business improvement
initiatives, business-enabling
initiatives to transform company
operations or new technology business
opportunity projects.
— May be classified as capital or operating
costs.
9-38
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Cost allocation:
— The process of allocating IT costs to
others’ budgets.
— Allocation may be based upon a
formula using factors such as size of
business unit, prior year spending, or
percentage of use of IT services.
— May lead to artificiality in allocating
development resources.
9-39
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
1. Fiscal Discipline
2. Strategy Implementation
9-40
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
“IT Costs too Much”.
Demonstrating the realities of business
finance has become a significant part of
IT leadership.
IT budgets may be used to limit or
manage demand.
Used to hold IT leadership accountable for
what it spends.
9-41
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Budgets link long-term goals to short-term
execution through the allocation of
resources.
Where IT dollars are spent can impact
corporate performance.
How discretionary IT dollars are spent
impacts project outcomes.
The budget process reinforces strategic
decision making.
9-42
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall 9-43
Figure 9.1 A Generic IT Planning and Budgeting Process
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Corporate processes:
— Establish corporate fiscal policy.
— Establish strategic goals.
— Set IT spending levels.
9-44
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Factors that Affect IT Spending Levels
Number of competitors
Uncertainty
Diversification of products and services
Affordability
Growth
Previous year’s spending
9-45
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
Set functional IT budget – determine
what is spent on IT operations and
strategic investment.
Set the fiscal IT budget – transform
the functional IT budget into operating
and capital spending categories.
9-46
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
1. Appoint an IT finance specialist
2. Use budgeting tools and methodologies
3. Separate operations from innovation
4. Adopt enterprise funding models
5. Adopt rolling budget cycles
9-47
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
1. IT finance specialist:
— Understand IT costs and drivers.
— Can manage the translation between
the IT functional and fiscal budget.
— Can develop business cases for new
projects.
9-48
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
2. Use budgeting tools and
methodologies
— Link IT Budgets to IT Plans.
— Link IT Budgets to Corporate Strategic
Plans.
— Link IT Budgets to Resource Strategies.
— Link IT Budgets to Performance
Metrics.
9-49
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
3. Separate operations from
innovation:
— Split operations costs from new project
development costs.
— Provide visibility to business unit
managers to better understand true
costs to deliver and service new
systems and ongoing services.
9-50
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
4. Adopt enterprise funding models:
— Separates centralized core IT services
from decentralized business unit
services.
— Used to develop IT operations budgets
at an enterprise level.
9-51
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
5. Adopt rolling budget cycles:
— IT Plans and budgets need updating
more than once per year.
— Quarterly eighteen month rolling plans
enable new projects to be funded more
quickly.
9-52
© © 2015 5 Pearson Education, Inc. . Publishing as Prentice Hall
The IT budget process can be a critical
lynchpin between many different
stakeholders: finance, business units,
corporate strategy, and IT.
IT budgets play a key role in
implementing strategy and controlling
costs.
9-53