Assignment 02: Broad Analogy
HA4110D – Healthcare Planning and Evaluation
Assignment 02: Broad Analogy
Instructions
Directions
.Read chapters 5-6 of the textbook.
.Review PowerPoints 5-6 of the textbook.
.Complete a full 2-page paper discussing the 5-forces as it relates to your organization.
.Provide a minimum of two issues per force and include all 5 forces.
.Provide the Issue-Impact-Implication
.Use the exercise sheet in chapter 6 pages 39-41 to assist in your learning.
.Use third person writings do not use “I think” or “in my opinion” keep it factual, third person and follow APA standards a minimum of two references are required.
Strategic Analysis for Healthcare
Chapter 5
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
1
Strategic Industry Map
Before you can begin to analyze the strengths of your organization and develop corresponding strategy, you need to understand the industry in which you operate.
To begin, many strategists will use a strategic industry map.
The industry map allows you to view your industry by size and category.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Strategic Industry Map
The industry map attempts to capture a snapshot of an entire industry in a way that allows for one quick glance to provide a high level of information.
First, a matrix is created.
The matrix will have two axes with two variables.
Typically, one axis will have some combination of price/quality/image, and the other axis will have some measure of product mix.
The analyst chooses any labels felt to be appropriate.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Beginning of a Strategic Industry Map
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Price / Quality / Image
High
Low
Medium
Product Mix
Private Practice
Healthcare Systems
Health Administration Press
Strategic Industry Map
Each industry segment is represented by a circle on the matrix, and each circle is placed at the appropriate intersection of the two axes.
The size of each circle represents the size of the industry segment relative to the other segments.
The example industry map displays the different size, quality, image, and product attributes of major players in healthcare. Note that the circles represent industry segments, not specific organizations.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Strategic Industry Map of the Healthcare Industry
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Price / Quality / Image
High
Low
Medium
Product Mix
Specialty
Healthcare
Broad-Category Healthcare
Healthcare systems
Teaching hospitals (tertiary care facilities)
Free-standing surgery centers
Chain providers (Wal Mart, etc.)-
Local acute care hospitals
Concierge service
Specialty surgical providers
Urgent care providers
Health Administration Press
Strategic Industry Map
Notice the area in the map that represents the intersection of low price and specialty care.
Is there a business opportunity there for an entrepreneurial provider? At one time there was.
When that corner of the map was unfilled, stores such as Wal-Mart, CVS, and Walgreens saw a demand for primary care and developed local walk-in clinics at many of their locations.
Time will tell how such efforts are received, but initial signs suggest they are successful.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Blue Ocean Strategy
Kim and Maugborgne (2005) identified wide open gaps in the industry map as “blue oceans”—uncontested spaces where no one competes.
“Red oceans” are places where competition already exists and has left “blood in the water.”
“Blue ocean strategy” involves seeking out uncontested market space and providing new market offerings.
Under those circumstances, the lack of competition can lead to quicker market dominance and higher profits.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Exercise
Break into groups of 5–8 and think of a healthcare organization. Then:
1. Identify the industry your organization is a part of and title your map appropriately.
2. Identify the appropriate axis labels to use on your map, such as price vs. breadth of product mix.
3. Identify the market segments within the market. Note that you are identifying market segments, not brands.
4. Identify the size of each of market segment.
5. Identify the attributes of each segment.
6. Place each market segment on the map, using the size of the circle to represent the size of the segment in dollar volume. Use the location on the map to correspond to the attributes you identified.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Exercise
After completing the map of your industry, answer the following questions:
Do you begin to see any weaknesses in the industry?
How about opportunities?
Are there any “blue oceans”?
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Strategic Analysis for Healthcare
Chapter 6
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
1
Five Forces in an Industry
Five forces analysis is a popular approach to analyzing industry factors that are likely to affect strategy.
The five forces shape, constrain, and provide opportunities for competitive advantage for your organization.
The forces influence how profitable a business in the particular industry will be, how much reasonable investment can be made into the industry, and how much growth opportunity exists in that industry.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Five Forces in an Industry
The five forces are
(1) threat of entry,
(2) intensity of rivalry,
(3) threat of substitute products,
(4) bargaining power of suppliers, and
(5) bargaining power of buyers.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Porter’s 5 Forces
Rivalry among existing firms
Bargaining power of sellers
Bargaining power of buyers
Threat of substitutes
Threat of entry
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Threat of Entry
The threat of new competitors entering a given market is one industry force that affects strategy.
If a company invests billions of dollars to create a new product that can be easily imitated by new entrants in the market, where is the competitive advantage?
On the other hand, if competitors are hard pressed to enter the market, a significant competitive advantage may exist for your company to move into the market first.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Threat of Entry
Threat of entry can be considered in terms of two main factors: (1) barriers to entry and (2) response of existing competitors.
Exhibit 6.2 in the book shows some potential barriers to entry.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Barriers to Entry
If there is one supplier of a critical component and your company has a contractually exclusive arrangement with that supplier, if a resource is scarce and you have it controlled, or if the dollar investment is prohibitively high for a competitor to justify entering the market, one would say the barrier to entry for a new entrant is high.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Response of Existing Competitors
Competitor responsiveness can lower the threat of entry if the existing competitors are well funded, have the ability to leverage well-established brand names, can aggressively cut prices and maintain low profit margins that would put new competitors out of business, or have a willingness to “defend their turf.”
Organizations will be less likely to invest large sums of money in a venture that might not get off the ground or might fail to deliver a generous rate of return on investment.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Intensity of Rivalry
The higher the intensity, the more difficult it will be for your organization to profit and grow in the market. A high intensity will also dictate a strong need for defensive strategies to protect your competitive advantages for as long as possible.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Threat of Substitute Products
The availability of substitute products limits the amount of money a company can charge for its product or service.
All things being equal, if prices rise, customers will switch to a cheaper competitor to substitute an equivalent product.
In reality, the competing options in a market are rarely equivalent. But when they are, the product is referred to as a “commodity” product—in other words, the product is perceived to be the same regardless of where it was purchased.
Crude oil is one example of a commodity product.
An example from the healthcare industry is generic drugs.
Is urgent care a substitute for the ER?
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Bargaining Power of Suppliers
The power held by raw material, component, subassembly, assembly, transportation, disposal, and other suppliers to companies in an industry directly affects the competitive nature of the industry.
The theory of supply and demand suggests that, if there are only a small number of suppliers of a necessary component, prices will rise. Suppliers can hold the corporate buyer “over a barrel.”
A category of supplier not found in general business consists of the physicians and surgeons who provide services to healthcare organizations.
Most are independent contractors who essentially provide labor to the hospitals.
Healthcare organizations must recognize the power of these providers and work to meet their needs through efficient and effective support services.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Bargaining Power of Buyers
The bargaining power of buyers is the opposite of the power of suppliers.
If large corporate buyers can shop around for their raw material, components, subassemblies, or other inputs and find lower prices, then these buyers have significant power over their suppliers.
Conditions through which industry buyers can gain bargaining power include the following:
The buyer buys in sufficiently large amounts to be able to demand lower prices.
The buyer buys in sufficiently large amounts to make the supplier dependent on the purchase.
The buyer has the ability to easily switch to a different supplier.
The buyer has the option of dropping the supplier and fulfilling its own need.
The buyer has the ability to buy a supplier and cut the current supplier out.
Quality or brand is unimportant to the business.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Analyzing the Five Forces
To assess the five forces, the analyst considers each force, one at a time.
The analyst identifies all the issues that impact the particular force, how each issue that has been identified affects the company, and what implications each issue has for strategy.
Exhibit 6.3 in the book provides an example of an analysis of the threat of entry for hospitals.
Note that “Implication for Strategy” is different from “Strategy.”
An implication for strategy identifies a broad possibility and allows for future brainstorming of many different strategies that could respond to that possibility.
In contrast, identifying a particular strategy here ends the discussion and shuts out other possible strategies that have not yet been considered. For example, Issue 4 in the exhibit has many possible strategic responses. If the issue had instead been addressed with “Buy out a supplier,” that strategy would be identified and the search for strategies would be over, eliminating other, maybe better, strategies that could have been developed.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Analyzing the Five Forces—
An Example
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Exercise
Divide into groups of 5–8.
Identify a healthcare organization and its industry.
Use the Five Forces Table at the end of Chapter 6 to brainstorm the five forces in the industry, related issues, impacts the issues have on the organization, and implications for strategy.
Copyright © 2016 Foundation of the American College of Healthcare Executives. Not for sale.
Health Administration Press
Health Administration Press
Force:Issue:
Impact on
Organization
Implication for
Strategy
Threat of entry
(Overall: low)
Government
regulation requires
licensing and
accreditation
of hospitals to
participate in
Medicare and
Medicaid programs.
Significant time
and resources are
spent in achieving
and maintaining
accreditation and
licenses.
Must include
strategies to
address
legal issues and
other
issues related to
accreditation.